From: bf3833@pyuxe.cc.bellcore.com (feigenbaum,benjamin)
Subject: Re: was:Go Hezbollah!
Organization: Bellcore, Livingston, NJ
Summary: An Untried Approach
Lines: 59

In article <1993Apr20.114746.3364@ncsu.edu>, hernlem@chess.ncsu.edu (Brad Hernlem) writes:
> 
> In article <1993Apr19.214300.17989@unocal.com>, stssdxb@st.unocal.com (Dorin Baru) writes:
> 
> |> (Brad Hernlem writes:
> |> 
> |> 
> |> >Well, you should have noted that I was cheering an attack on an Israeli 
> |> >patrol INSIDE Lebanese territory while I was condemning the "retaliatory"
> |> >shelling of Lebanese villages by Israeli and Israeli-backed forces. My "team",
> |> >you see, was "playing fair" while the opposing team was rearranging the
> |> >faces of the spectators in my team's viewing stands, so to speak. 
> |> 
> |> >I think that you should try to find more sources of news about what goes on
> |> >in Lebanon and try to see through the propaganda. There are no a priori
> |> >black and white hats but one sure wonders how the IDF can bombard villages in 
> |> >retaliation to pin-point attacks on its soldiers in Lebanon and then call the
> |> >Lebanese terrorists.
> |> 
> |> If the attack was justified or not is at least debatable. But this is not the
> |> issue. The issue is that you were cheering DEATH. [...]
> |> 
> |> Dorin
> 
> Dorin, of all the criticism of my post expressed on t.p.m., this one I accept.
> I regret that aspect of my post. It is my hope that the occupation will end (and
> the accompanying loss of life) but I believe that stiff resistance can help to 
> achieve that end. Despite what some have said on t.p.m., I think that there is 
> a point when losses are unacceptable. The strategy drove U.S. troops out of 
> Lebanon, at least.
> 
> Brad Hernlem (hernlem@chess.ncsu.EDU)

Hi Brad,

I have two comments:  Regarding your hope that the "occupation will end... 
belive that stiff resistance..etc. - how about an untried approach, i.e.,
peace and cooperation.  I can't help but wonder what would happen if all
violence against Israelis stopped.  Hopefully, violence against Arabs
would stop at the same time.  If a state of non-violence could be 
maintained, perhaps a state of cooperation could be achieved, i.e.,
greater economic opportunities for both peoples living in the
"territories".  

Of course, given the current leadership of Israel, your way may work
also - but if that leadership changes, e.g., to someone with Ariel
Sharon's mentality, then I would predict a considerable loss of life,
i.e., no winners.

Secondly, regarding your comment about the U.S. troops responding
to "stiff resistance" - the analogy is not quite valid.  The U.S.
troops could get out of the neighborhood altogether.  The Israelis
could not.

Just my $.02 worth, no offense intended.

Respectfully,     

Ben.